It was Aristotle that echoed in latin “Amicus Plato, sed magis amica veritas” meaning Plato is my friend, but truth is a better friend.
Permit me to contribute to the raging debate on the appropriate tier of government to collect and spend in a winner takes all manner instead of the present 15:50:35 sharing formula in favour of the Federal, State and Local Governments. It is pertinent to trace the genesis of the VAT regime in Nigeria in order to appreciate the position of the altercating parties.
The Federal Military Government under General Babangida is reputed to have scored several great goals and own goals in equal measure, though more remembered for the missed decisive kick in the shootout with the annulled June 12 election that forced the regime to step aside 28 years ago. The Value Added Tax (VAT) Act No. 102 of 1993 was an offshoot of the repealed Decree 7 of 1986 nurtured Sales Tax. The inherent loopholes and inefficiencies in the States’ administered Sales Tax birthed the noble harmonisation idea by the Babangida regime in 1991 when the then Minister of Finance Alhaji Abubakar Alhaji head hunted Emmanuel Ijewere to lead a committee including Prof. Sam Aluko in creating a robust consumption Tax system. The committee made a recommendation to the Federal Military Government that a VAT Commission should be established for the purpose of administration and a deduction of 5% is to be withheld by the VAT Commission as running cost, while the 95% is shared amongst States on the ‘basis of collection’, this was further altered to ratio 80/20 in favour of the States and 20% as cost of administration that metamorphosed into ratio 50:25:25 in favour of the Federal, State and Local Governments preceding the current 15:50:35. Lest we forget, the Sales Tax belonged to the States and Federal Government merely stepped in as the tax reformer for the purpose of enhancing efficiency and not as beneficiary of generated revenue.
On the return to civil rule, the neglect of the basis of collection principle which in local parlance translates to ‘No Contribution, No Chop’ (NCNC) as Sales Tax or VAT is a consumption tax forced the Lagos State Government to challenge the provisions of the Act as to the appropriate tier of Government required to administer VAT/Sales Tax which culminated in the re-introduction of the abrogated Sales Tax in the State – an act that is another catalyst for litigation, the mantle has fallen on Governor Wike to like the Lagos stance, the unitary approach to government by the Federal Military Government (an anomaly, can a Military Government ever be Federal?) as the subdued states are now finding the lost voice. My advice is that we should not forget the reasons why the inefficient and ill administered Sales Tax was abrogated in the first instance, if reasons why the Sales Tax failed are ignored, though I am not Baba Awolowo, but something within me tells me, loud and clear that we have embarked on a fruitless search and at the end of the day, when we imagine that the new order is here, we would be terribly disappointed!